Practice Strengths

IP Litigation

Baker Hostetler represents clients in all types of Intellectual Property (IP) cases before juries, judges, arbitrators and federal agencies. No matter what forum or dispute resolution process is being used, we are able to translate the issues into readily understandable language. We work with our clients in all types of IP litigation to make sure the most effective team of lawyers is deployed. Our patent litigation teams usually consist of jury trial lawyers joined by patent lawyers with relevant scientific and technical backgrounds. Additionally, as a result of our firm's long history in the fields of anti-counterfeiting and trademark and copyright infringement, we have a dedicated team of lawyers and nationwide protocols in place to mobilize and seek ex parte seizures and temporary restraining orders from courts around the nation on short notice.

Our experience also includes effective representation of clients in specialized proceedings, such as the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) trademark oppositions and cancellation actions, Section 337 proceedings at the International Trade Commission (ITC), border control through the U.S. Customs Service proceedings, and proceedings at the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and appeals before the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit -- the exclusive appellate panel for adjudicating the appeals of patent infringement cases. Our worldwide capabilities extend to non-U.S. courts and agencies through Baker Hostetler's network of affiliates and affiliated offices.

We endeavor to understand the business objectives of the IP litigation in which our clients are involved and to keep the nature, tone and cost of the litigation within the context of those objectives. This requires us to maintain a constant flow of communication regarding any available litigation options and to manage cost expectations.

Leadership in Action
IP Litigation: Successfully representing one of the largest shirt manufacturers in the world accused of patent infringement
Client: Esquel Enterprises, Ltd. Of Wanchai, Hong Kong, and Esquel Apparel, Inc. of New York, New York
Type of Matter: ITC Section 337 Investigation
Our Client's Challenge: Alleged infringement of claims in five different U.S. patents owned by TAL Apparel Limited of Hong Kong (and related entities).
The Goal: Ensure that client's products are not barred from the U.S. market.
Our Strategy: Rapidly gather evidence and present arguments on all issues.
Results: Successfully secured the withdrawal of all allegations of infringement against the Esquel companies.
Read More

About Our Intellectual Property Team

Our team of dedicated IP lawyers and patent agents has the diverse backgrounds and core strengths required to ensure that the full spectrum of domestic and international IP is considered in securing IP and formulating IP strategies. Members of our IP team have worked as engineers and in-house patent, trademark and copyright counsel for companies and agencies as diverse as Borg Warner, Capitol Records, DuPont, the USPTO, the Justice Department (Civil Division, Intellectual Property) and the FTC.

Our team members also include adjunct IP law professors, columnists, the co-founder of the longest-running journal on computer technology and regular lecturers for the Zurich Institute of Technology, Georgetown University and George Mason University. In addition, our team members frequently speak and write for continuing legal education programs and industry events and are quoted in the press on emerging issues.

Baker Hostetler is a member of the International Trademark Association (INTA), American Intellectual Property Law Association (AIPLA), Intellectual Property Owners Association (IPO), Licensing Executive Society (LES), The International AntiCounterfeiting Coalition (IACC), International Licensing Industry and Merchandisers Association (LIMA), as well as numerous local and regional IP organizations.

Leadership in Action
IP Litigation: Successfully representing one of the largest shirt manufacturers in the world accused of patent infringement
Client: Esquel Enterprises, Ltd. Of Wanchai, Hong Kong, and Esquel Apparel, Inc. of New York, New York
Type of Matter: ITC Section 337 Investigation
Our Client's Challenge: Alleged infringement of claims in five different U.S. patents owned by TAL Apparel Limited of Hong Kong (and related entities).
The Goal: Ensure that client's products are not barred from the U.S. market.
Our Strategy: Rapidly gather evidence and present arguments on all issues.
Results: Successfully secured the withdrawal of all allegations of infringement against the Esquel companies.

Leadership in Action
Patents: Realizing the value of patents
Client: ImagExpo, L.L.C., a subsidiary of SPX Corporation, a multibillion-dollar global provider of technical products and systems, industrial products and services, flow technology and service solutions
Type of Matter: Patent infringement case in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia.
Our Client's Challenge: Patent infringement suit brought by ImagExpo to enforce a patent relating to collaborative software.
The Goal: Obtain damages for past infringement.
Our Strategy: Brought suit in the Eastern District of Virginia, known as the "rocket docket," to bring suit to trial quickly.
Results: Obtained a favorable settlement for ImagExpo/SPX Corporation.

Leadership in Action
Trademarks: Protecting a sporting association's right to use images of its sport as trademarks
Client: United States Polo Association (USPA)
Type of Matter: Trademark infringement case in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.
Our Client's Challenge: Polo Ralph Lauren filed a lawsuit which sought an injunction barring USPA from using four logos featuring two men playing polo on horses on licensed goods including clothing, leather goods, watches and sporting equipment.
The Goal: Convince the jury that USPA, as the governing body of the sport, had the right to use images of polo being played in a licensing program despite the fame of the Ralph Lauren polo player.
Our Strategy: Educate the jury to better understand the sport of polo, the people who play it and their legitimate interest in supporting the sport by selling goods bearing images of the sport.
Results: The jury unanimously found that three of the four trademarks adopted by the USPA did not infringe Polo Ralph Lauren's trademark rights.

Leadership in Action
Transactions: Going to court in the defendant’s home base to protect a distribution agreement
Client: A large Canadian toy company
Type of Matter: Breach of distribution agreement in Federal District Court.
Our Client's Challenge: Our client had secured rights to distribute a famous plush toy in Canada, along with promises from the rights owner to take action against infringements. The toys were delivered late, and unauthorized copies dominated the Canadian market, despite our client's requests to the owner to take action. Our client was not able to sell the anticipated quantities of licensed products once they arrived.
The Goal: Recover lost profits.
Our Strategy: When business negotiations failed, litigation was instituted in the United States for breach of the agreement--late delivery and failure to stop the infringements.
Results: Obtained a jury verdict and damages in favor of our client, and the matter was resolved later privately.


Intellectual Property—IP Litigation Lawyers
Bukola T. Aina Associate
Washington, DC 202.861.1545
Bruce O. Baumgartner Partner
Cincinnati 513.929.3417
Robertson D. Beckerlegge Associate
New York 212.589.4209
John F. Bennett Associate
Cincinnati 513.929.3485
Fernando A. Bohorquez, Jr. Partner
New York 212.589.4242
Peter Brown Partner
New York 212.589.4660
Seanna R. Brown Associate
New York 212.589.4230
Lisa I. Carteen Partner
Los Angeles 310.979.8450
Matthew J. Cavanagh Associate
Cleveland 216.861.6488
Melanie S. Corcoran Staff Attorney
Cleveland 216.861.7659
James A. Dimitrijevs Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7579
Breaden M. Douthett Counsel
Cleveland 216.861.7891
David A. Einhorn Partner
New York 212.589.4644
James V. Etscorn Partner
Orlando 407.649.4067
Gerald J. Ferguson Partner
New York 212.589.4238
Matthew P. Hayden Associate
Cincinnati 513.929.3418
Robert B.G. Horowitz Partner
New York 212.589.4240
Kevin W. Kirsch Partner
Cincinnati 513.929.3499
David E. Kitchen Associate
Cleveland 216.861.7060
Richard M. Knoth Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7412
Richard M. Lehrer Partner
New York 212.589.4618
Michael R. Levin Partner
Orlando 407.649.4698
C. Dennis Loomis Partner
Los Angeles 310.442.8865
Hanna F. Madbak Associate
New York 212.589.4608
David A. Mancino Partner
Cincinnati 513.929.3495
Heather J. McDonald Partner
New York 212.589.4285
Hayes F. Michel Partner
Los Angeles 310.979.8460
John M. Mings Partner
Houston 713.646.1380
Grant A. Monachino Associate
Cleveland 216.861.7357
Christina J. Moser Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7818
Phong D. Nguyen Partner
Washington, DC 202.861.1610
Jason S. Oliver Associate
New York 212.589.4649
Louisa T. Ryan Associate
Washington, DC 202.861.1703
A. Neal Seth Partner
Washington, DC 202.861.1775
David J. Sheehan Partner
New York 212.589.4616
Kenneth J. Sheehan Partner
Washington, DC 202.861.1682
Thomas H. Shunk Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7592
Victor Siber Partner
New York 212.589.4696
Mark H. Tidman Partner
Washington, DC 202.861.1670
Adam M. Treiber Of Counsel
Washington, DC 202.861.1707
Oren J. Warshavsky Partner
New York 212.589.4624
W. Breck Weigel Partner
Cincinnati 513.929.3490
Deborah A. Wilcox Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7864
Date Intellectual Property—IP Litigation News
3/11/2010 2010 "Rising Stars" Announced
3/11/2010 2010 "Super Lawyers" Announced
1/29/2010 Horowitz Featured in "Expert Guide"
1/22/2010 Law360: Baker Hostetler Boosts IP Practice With Taft Hires
1/15/2010 Cincinnati Office Adds IP Partners David Mancino & Kevin Kirsch
1/8/2010 Etscorn to Lead Baker Hostetler’s Orlando Office
1/5/2010 Baker Hostetler Announces New Partners
12/17/2009 Wilcox Chairs "2009 Intellectual Property Update"
12/10/2009 IP Practice Ranked in Top 30
11/19/2009 Wilcox Addresses PubCon and SMX Conferences
9/28/2009 Bohorquez Panelist on eDiscovery at HNBA Annual Convention
9/23/2009 McDonald Addresses AOAIOIP Conference
8/10/2009 "Best Lawyers in America" Recognizes 94 Baker Hostetler Attorneys
7/13/2009 Wilcox Assumes Leadership Positions with CMBA & CIPLA
6/12/2009 Chambers USA Names 36 "Leading Business Lawyers"
6/1/2009 Inside Business: Northeast Ohio's Young Legal Leaders
5/19/2009 IP Practice Ranked in Top 10 Percent
5/18/2009 Moser Addresses OSBA's Intellectual Property Section
4/23/2009 Bohorquez Appointed to NY Bar Association’s House of Delegates
4/16/2009 Expansion of Cincinnati Office Continues with Addition of Breck Weigel
2/24/2009 Veteran Intellectual Property Lawyer Victor Siber Joins New York Office
2/16/2009 Bohorquez Presents Resolution on Guantánamo Detainees to the ABA
1/9/2009 Baker Hostetler Announces New Associates
1/8/2009 George Stamboulidis Named Managing Partner of New York Office
12/8/2008 Baker Hostetler Named a “Go-To Law Firm” For 2009
11/13/2008 Wilcox Addresses WebmasterWorld's Search & Internet Marketing Conference
10/30/2008 Los Angeles Office Expands with Addition of Hayes Michel
07/15/2008 NY Office Expands with Team of IP Attorneys
05/01/2008 Technology Law Pioneer Brown Joins Firm
04/03/2008 Firm Expands IP Practice & NY Office with Addition of Horowitz and Tobin
Date Intellectual Property—IP Litigation Articles
3/9/2010 New York Law Journal: Active Inducement in the Post-Grokster World
1/28/2010 Fashion Law: A Guide for Designers, Fashion Executives, and Attorneys
12/28/2009 Intellectual Property Counselor: Intellectual Property Rights in Government Contracting
11/30/2009 National Law Journal: Registering Marks as Top-Level Domain Names
1//17/2009 IPFrontline: Important Issues In TTAB Cancellation Proceedings
11/1/2009 Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Journal: Dealing With Consumer-Generated Content on Social Networking Sites
9/18/2009 BNA's Patent, Trademark & Copyright Journal: Overuse of the Inequitable Conduct Defense
8/12/2009 New York Law Journal: Electronic Health Records: Facing the Issues
7/27/2009 Government Contract Litigation Reporter: Intellectual Property Rights In Government Contracting
7/2/2009 ABA Business Law eNewsletter:Changing Landscape: Introduction to the Third Amendment to the Chinese Patent Law
6/2/2009 Law360: License To Lawsuit: The Path Grows Shorter
6/1/2009 FEDA News & Views: Is Your Business Domain at Risk?
4/21/2009 NAMESMASH.COM: Cybersquatters Use India Courts To Stall Legal Action
2/1/2009 The Licensing Journal: Unauthorized Guidebooks on Character Properties
10/17/2008 New York Law Journal: DMCA: A Safe Harbor for Video Sharing?
10/15/2008 Wisconsin Technology Network: Online Tracking and the Privacy Violations of Behavioral Marketing
10/1/2008 The Licensing Journal: Special Terms in Fan Kit Licenses
6/1/2008 The Licensing Journal: Beyond VeRO: Enforcement of Character-Related Auctions on eBay
4/1/2008 The Licensing Journal: Privacy Issues in the Internationalization of Character-Related Websites
Date Intellectual Property—IP Litigation Quotes
3/10/2010 AmLaw Daily: Litigator of the Week
3/1/2010 Crain's Cleveland Business: In Data Breaches, Repairing Reputation as Important as Legal Obligation
2/15/2010 AOL News: New York Cracks Down on Knockoff Artists
2/3/2010 New York Times: In Court, Impassioned Challenges of Madoff Trustee’s Plans
1/22/2010 Law360: Songwriter Sampled In 'My Humps' Wins Copyright Feud
1/15/2010 Cincinnati Business Courier: Cleveland Law Firm Takes Two from Taft
1/8/2010 Orlando Business Journal: Baker Hostetler Names New Managing Partner for Orlando Office
1/7/2010 The New Yorker: Number Nine
12/21/2009 BNA's Privacy & Security Law Report: Massachusetts Justices Dismiss Credit Union Claims in BJ's Payment Card Breach Lawsuit
12/15/2009 Harper's Bazaar: The Fight Against Faux Fragrances
12/15/2009 Harper's Bazaar: Friend or Faux? The Fight Against Fashion Fakes
9/27/2009 60 Minutes: The Liquidator
8/23/2009 New York Post/FoxNews.com: Jett in Battle of the Ex-Band
7/20/2009 China Daily (US Edition): The Bag Ladies of Chinatown
7/1/2009 Women's Wear Daily: Judge Sotomayor's Fashionable Past
4/17/2009 Business Courier of Cincinnati: Cincinnati Law Office Lands Another Prominent Player
2/25/2009 IP Law 360: Baker Hostetler Nabs Clifford Chance, IBM IP Vet
1/23/2009 Christian Science Monitor: A Case of Cold Plagiarism?
1/7/2009 Harper's Bazaar: The Fight Against Fakes
12/30/2008 MSNBC.com: Joe Satriani May Have a Case Against Coldplay
12/10/2008 Reuters: Mattel and MGA Better Off Settling on Bratz
11/10/2008 Bloomberg News: Mattel, Back in Court, Seeks to Seize MGA Bratz Dolls, Ban Them
For more information on our Intellectual Property Litigation practice:
National Contact

John H. Weber

202.861.1526
Chicago
Ronald S. Okada 312.416.6210

Cincinnati

David G. Holcombe 513.929.3402
Cleveland

Thomas H. Shunk

216.861.7592

Deborah A.Wilcox

216.861.7864

Columbus

Daniel J. Gunsett

614.462.2642
Costa Mesa
George T. Mooradian 714.966.8800    
Denver
Raymond L. Sutton 303.764.4103   
Houston
Lisa H. Pennington 713.646.1303
Los Angeles
C. Dennis Loomis 310.442.8865
New York

Gerald J. Ferguson

212.589.4238
Orlando

James V. Etscorn

407.649.4067
Washington, DC
Kenneth J. Sheehan 202.861.1682

Contact

National Contact
John H. Weber
202.861.1526


Contacts by Office »

Practice Highlights

A team of more than 50 dedicated IP lawyers, patent agents and scientific experts, many with advanced technical degrees in fields such as nuclear engineering, electronics, biotechnology, aerospace controls, chemicals and software and circuit design.

Patent, trademark and copyright clearance opinions, prosecution, counseling and licensing both domestically and worldwide, through our network of associated lawyers and agents.

Patent, trademark, unfair competition, copyright and trade secret litigation within federal courts, the ITC, the TTAB, the FTC, ICANN and other administrative agencies both domestically and worldwide, through our network of associated lawyers and agents.

Transaction and “best practices” counseling that ranges from due diligence, formulation of IP standard operating procedures, employee and contractor agreements, joint development agreements, product and process clearance opinions to infringement/ non-infringement opinions.

Management and monitoring services of large global patent and trademark portfolios for multinational clients.