Articles

Danyll Foix Article Explains Why "Failing Firm" Defense Could Not Save Waste Companies' Deal

Articles / August 22, 2017

Partner Danyll Foix authored an analysis published by Law360 on July 19, 2017. The article, “The ‘Failing Firm’ Defense: Pointers from a Blocked Deal,” offers insight into the failed deal between EnergySolutions and Waste Control Specialists. A federal judge ruled that the terms of the acquisition agreement precluded the parties from relying on the “failing firm” defense to save the deal from being blocked on antitrust grounds.

Foix’s article discusses the deal and the “failed firm” arguments, and concludes:


“The blocked EnergySolutions/WCS merger provides a few pointers for parties considering acquisitions that are likely to draw scrutiny from antitrust enforcers. Most obviously, parties that anticipate relying on a failing firm defense should avoid transaction provisions that hinder a thorough, good-faith process for identifying potential buyers. This does not mean that parties cannot agree to exclusive negotiation, or no-talk, terms. Rather, such terms may be adopted after completing a process that confirms the lack of reasonable alternative buyers for a failing firm. And if that is not possible, the parties still may be able to prove there were no alternative buyers through post-transaction evidence or cooperation with the enforcers.”

Read the article (registration required).

Blog

In The Blogs

Previous Next
Antitrust Advocate
Carl Hittinger, Jeanne-Michele Mariani Article Takes a Look at Antitrust Division’s Renewed Focus on Bid Rigging
June 19, 2019
Partner Carl Hittinger and Associate Jeanne-Michele Mariani authored an article published May 8, 2019, by The Legal Intelligencer. The article, “Antitrust Division’s Renewed Focus on Bid Rigging Promises to be Perilous,” focuses on the...
Read More ->
Antitrust Advocate
Carl Hittinger, Tyson Herrold Article Examines Antitrust Legacy of Former Chief Judge Dolores Sloviter
May 21, 2019
Partner Carl Hittinger and Associate Tyson Herrold authored an article published on April 12, 2019, by Temple University’s business law publication, The Temple 10-Q. The article, “Judge Dolores K. Sloviter’s Antitrust Legacy,” discusses...
Read More ->
Antitrust Advocate
Carl Hittinger, Jeanne-Michele Mariani Author Article Examining NCAA’s Monopoly Status
April 10, 2019
Partner Carl Hittinger, the Antitrust and Competition team leader, and Associate Jeanne-Michele Mariani authored an article published in the March 29, 2019, issue of The Legal Intelligencer. The article, “The NCAA, Which Is Tied to...
Read More ->
Antitrust Advocate
Carl Hittinger, Julian Perlman Article Examines Antitrust Legacy of Judge Thomas Vanaskie
March 11, 2019
Partner Carl Hittinger and Counsel Julian Perlman authored an article published March 1, 2019, by The Legal Intelligencer. The article, “Circuit Judge Thomas Vanaskie’s Antitrust Legacy: 2 Significant Cases,” examines opinions issued by...
Read More ->
Antitrust Advocate
Vertical Merger Review Debate Continues With Antitrust Enforcers
By Danyll W. Foix
February 26, 2019
Since at least 2017, when the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) sued to block a vertical merger, the business press has been atwitter about the antitrust enforcement agencies’ views of such mergers, as we covered here. The Federal Trade...
Read More ->