Jacqueline Matthews Examines Circuit Split over "Ascertainability" in Class Actions

News / April 27, 2016

Associate Jacqueline Matthews authored an article published by Law360 on April 25, 2016. The article, “Class Cert. Unclear with Circuit Split on Ascertainability,” originated as a post on the firm’s Class Action Lawsuit Defense blog. Matthews writes about the divide between the Third and Seventh Circuits over the meaning of the “ascertainability” prerequisite to class certification. She notes that the circuits disagree as to whether plaintiffs must propose an administratively feasible method for identifying class members at the class certification stage, and concludes:

[A]t least for the foreseeable future, class action defendants’ ability to rely on the ascertainability standard to avoid class certification will depend on the circuit in which they find themselves.

Read the article (registration required).

Related Services


In The Blogs

Previous Next
Class Action Lawsuit Defense
Seventh Circuit Ties Class Counsel’s Recovery of Attorneys’ Fees to Amount Claimed by Class, in Context of a Judgment
November 20, 2017
On November 14, 2017, the Seventh Circuit issued its third opinion ending a class action that was almost a decade old. Holtzman v. Turza, No. 17-2330, 2017 WL 5450484 (7th Cir. Nov. 14, 2017). The class action alleged that the defendant...
Class Action Lawsuit Defense
TCPA Class Denied Certification Due to Binding Authority of Yaakov and Proof of Individualized Issues of Consent
November 13, 2017
A recent order from the Northern District of Illinois granted a defendant’s motion to deny class certification regarding “unsolicited” fax advertisements allegedly sent in violation of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). The...
Class Action Lawsuit Defense
Eleventh Circuit Outlines the Key to an Individual Arbitration Agreement
October 10, 2017
The Eleventh Circuit recently upheld an arbitration agreement in a consumer class action involving checking overdraft fees. In Johnson v. KeyBank N.A., 11th Cir. No. 15-10779 (Sept. 26, 2017), the plaintiffs brought a putative class action...
Class Action Lawsuit Defense
Corporation and Its Managers Held in Civil Contempt for Failing to Comply With Settlement Final Approval Order
September 26, 2017
Last month, Global Fitness Holdings LLC and its four managers were held in civil contempt for failure to comply with a final order approving a class action settlement. Gascho v. Global Fitness Holdings, LLC, S.D. Ohio No. 2:11-cv-436 (Aug...
Class Action Lawsuit Defense
Seventh Circuit Rejects Subway Footlong Class Settlement as a “Racket”
September 19, 2017
A recent Seventh Circuit decision pushed back on a proposed settlement of the Subway “footlong sub” class action, finding the proposed settlement a “racket” designed to benefit class counsel without any benefit to the class. The story...