Practice Strengths

Product Liability and Toxic Tort

Prevention and Defense
Our firm strives to protect the integrity of a client's product and reputation. Our product liability and toxic tort attorneys resolve and litigate cases from manufacturing defects and product misuse to individual chemical exposure and class action claims.

We understand that in today's climate, nearly every matter in this area of law can threaten a company's core business. Regardless of the size or scope of a matter, we address the scientific, technical and medical issues of product liability and toxic injury cases. We also, as preventive measures, develop claim prevention plans and assist clients with product design and warning programs.

Our goal is to provide ongoing, seamless communications with our clients, utilizing extranets, document banks, secure online discussion tools and other methods to maximize efficiency. At the earliest stages of our relationship with a client, we discuss litigation-minimization and cost-saving strategies such as: alternative dispute resolution, early case analysis, and post-matter assessments to review successes, outcomes and lessons learned.

Product Liability
We litigate product liability cases across the country resolving claims of design defect, duty to warn, product misuse, post delivery product tampering and other allegations. These claims involve such injury claims as psychological, neurological, chemical hypersensitivity, immune system disorders and fear of future injuries due to chemical exposure.

Additional Resources
We supplement legal counsel with technical, medical and other scientific support to defend clients in the simplest to the most complex cases. We're resourceful, using not only our national team of attorneys, but also highly regarded witnesses with significant understanding of the products involved in claims against our clients, including:
  • after-market automotive
    products
  • building materials
  • chemical products
  • construction equipment
  • construction failures
  • consumer products
  • farm machinery
  • foods
  • hazardous materials
  • heating and cooling vessels
  • industrial machinery
  • manufacturing and processing
  • medical devices
  • motor vehicles (autos,
    tow motors, trucks)
  • oilfield equipment and
    gas pipelines
  • paints
  • prescription drugs
  • pressure vessels
  • roofing products
  • small appliances
  • solvents
  • swimming pool and pump
    accidents
  • theme park rides
  • tobacco products
  • water slides

 

 

 

 

 

 

Toxic Tort
Baker Hostetler lawyers have extensive experience defending mass tort cases. Our lawyers have served both as national counsel--advising clients on and implementing overall strategies, and as regional and local counselhandling the day-to-day work and trying cases for dozens of clients in tens of thousands of cases in numerous jurisdictions and trying cases all over the country.

Our experience places us among the nation's top toxic tort law firms. Due in part to our asbestos work for GAF, the Asbestos Claims Facility and the Center for Claims Resolutions, we are current with the most recent legal theories and practices for managing significant mass tort cases.

We have served as a "National Coordinating Counsel" as well as regional and local counsel for clients in their defense of many different products. Our nearly 40 years of toxic tort experience includes environmental disasters, such as the Exxon Valdez oil spill, and tragedies, such as the Beverly Hills Supper Club fire. In these and other matters we serve clients as local, regional and national counsel.

Our Toxic Tort team, which incorporates attorneys and paralegals from all of the firm's offices, handles every size of case, from individual actions regarding single exposures, to mass individual filings, to nationwide class actions.

Additional Resources
We work daily with medical and scientific experts who provide cutting-edge consultation crucial to toxic tort litigation. We have called on these experts to assist us in cases involving dozens of substances, including:

  • acids and tailings
  •  "Gulf War Syndrome"
  • aluminum wire anhydrous ammonia
  • asbestos
  • asbestos containing products
  • "BTEX"
  • benzene
  • benzopyrene
  • beryllium
  • butadiene
  • chlordane
  • coal tar
  • DES
  • DPT vaccine
  • fiberglass
  • formaldehyde
  • hydrogen sulfide
  • isocyanates
  • lead
  • L-tryptophan
  • maleic anhydride
  • methylene chloride
  • NORM
  • PCBs
  • PCE
  • peroxides
  • pesticides
  • petroleum hydrocarbons
  • Phosgene
  • printing ink
  • PTFE
  • radioactive waste
  • silica
  • silicone/saline
  • solvents
  • styrene
  • sulfur dioxide
  • TCE
  • TDI
  • Tetracycline
  • TMA (trimethylamine)
  • vinyl chloride

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Our cases concerning these and other toxic materials have helped us develop important technical experience and contacts in the medical and scientific communities. This is invaluable in understanding how to communicate complex matters concerning the cardiovascular and central nervous systems and related dysfunctions, including: multiple chemical sensitivity, connective tissue disorders, cancer, diseases of the lungs, toxic encephalopathy, organic brain disease, polyneuropathy and multiple other neurological, physiological and psychological disorders.

Emergency Response
Our Emergency Response Team serves clients nationwide.  Lawyers in each of our offices are on call 24 hours a day and dispatched to an incident site immediately following our notification of a mishap.

In an emergency response situation, clients need to focus on bringing a situation under control and moving toward the resumption of normal business operations. In furthering that goal, our Emergency Response Team can establish and maintain productive working relationships with investigatory agencies, insurance companies, legitimate claimants, employees and other stakeholders.

We understand and manage reporting obligations and responses to citations and enforcement actions with OSHA, U.S. and state environmental protection agencies, USCG, and other authorities. We provide assistance with safety, health and environmental compliance issues involving the Code of Federal Regulations, such as process safety, hazardous materials and other environmental regulations.

Baker Hostetler also assists clients prior to the onset of a crisis. We perform environmental and related audits, develop regulatory compliance plans, conduct risk management, litigation and insurance coverage analyses, and advise companies on the preparation of their own emergency response plans.

We are among the nation's top toxic tort law firms, with experience ranging from asbestos exposure to environmental disasters.

Baker Hostetler's Emergency Response and Crisis Management team can be contacted toll-free, 24 hours a day, at
(888) 360-7908.

Leadership in Action
Product Liability: Establishing an effective strategy for pesticide litigation defense
Client: Pesticide Manufacturers
Type of Matter: Product liability defense
Our Client's Challenge: Numerous lawsuits have been brought against our clients for alleged injuries and damages involving use of pesticide products.
The Goal: Demonstrate that federal law shields our client from product liability allegations.
Our Strategy: Baker Hostetler was a leader in developing the argument that the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) preempts the claims based directly or indirectly on products warnings.
Results: We have won numerous cases with this defense and written amicus briefs in the Texas Supreme Court and the United States Supreme Court on this issue.


pdfpagebreak

Product Liability Experience

  • Settled more than 50 cases concerning post-collision fuel tank fires.
  • Defended 300 breast implant cases.
  • Won summary judgment summary judgment ruling and rejection of a client's market share liability in 500 DES cases in a state Supreme Court.
  • Won three consecutive trial victories for clients concerning medical devices and pharmaceuticals.
  • Defended client in temporomandibular joint implant litigation (in excess of 5,000 claims), with dismissal of client from the litigation which was upheld on appeal.
  • Defended client in litigation involving sensitivity to latex gloves, including numerous claims and MDL.
  • Won a jury verdict in favor of the equipment manufacturer we defended in a case concerning the explosion of a cam lock coupling.
  • Won a defense verdict in a case involving a solvent product that exploded and burned the user's face and body.
  • Gained dismissal on technical and procedural issues of several hundred cases relating to diethylstilbestrol, which involved the earliest application of market share liability.
  • Resolved of multiple UST exposures for major oil company, including ancillary regulatory liabilities.
  • Won summary judgment for client in thousands of community exposure cases related to refinery and plant emissions.
  • Won dismissals of lawsuits involving inhalation of toxic solvents.
  • Resolved numerous death cases resulting from the misdelivery of gas products to a nursing home; and the successful management of the defense of the company in the unprecedented criminal prosecution that resulted from the incident.
  • Earned dismissal of a lawsuit involving claims of lung damage from alleged inhalation of fumes from flat-tire repair products.
  • Won a defense verdict in favor of an appliance manufacturer in a case concerning a fire that destroyed a residence.
  • Defended a client accused of selling food products containing salmonella.
  • Won de minimis settlement of claims for seven deaths related to alleged failure of electrical appliance in mobile home.
  • Won de minimis settlement of eight figure liability for warehousing of hazardous chemicals destroyed by fire allegedly caused by improperly compounded batch rubber.
  • Defended client in cases involving an underwater ladder pump for a dredge, aerial lift bucket, cranes, downhole oil field drilling equipment, natural gas recovery, petroleum pipeline valves, tank cleaning solvent and an underground crude oil spill.

Toxic Tort Experience

  • Defended a client who had a water fountain on its grounds that was found to be the source of Legionella bacteria responsible for contaminating guests with Legionnaire's disease.
  • Won dismissals and summary judgments of more than 10,000 asbestos personal injury cases.
  • Defended against 30 cases of alleged exposure to methylene chloride and isocyanates.
  • Won a favorable state Supreme Court ruling that a client's warning was adequate in defense of alleged injuries caused by the client's vaccine.
  • Won summary judgment and dismissals in favor of clients in mass tort/class action/community exposure cases related to landfills and Superfund sites.
  • Defended against class certification and assisted clients in structuring favorable class designations in instances where class action treatment was the most efficient means of case management and resolution.
  • Defended clients in toxic exposure cases and management of OSHA and USCG investigations.

Emergency Response Experience
Our emergency response experience includes plant explosions, workplace fatalities, oil spills and chemical releases. Specific examples include:

  • Tank Farm Release – A large release of petroleum and aviation jet fuel forced the evacuation of homes in a nearby community. Baker Hostetler was part of a crisis management team coordinating the company's response. Our assistance included client communications and negotiations with the EPA (federal and state), the city and the county, while later defending the company in a series of suits filed by commercial entities and homeowners.
  • Chemical Plant Disaster – A chemical plant explosion killed three workers, destroyed several one-million-gallon storage tanks, and reportedly contaminated the nearby Ohio River. We managed all environmental investigations and litigation matters. The court denied a motion for class certification and the plant was rebuilt without any legal or regulatory delays.
  • Plastic Catalyst Plant Explosion – Explosions at a plastic catalyst plant and surrounding buildings forced the evacuation of nearby homes. Dozens of local residents went to area hospitals for treatment of respiratory conditions and other potential health problems allegedly related to the explosion. Members of our Emergency Response Team were soon on the scene of the incident and assisted in dealing with OSHA, the EPA (federal and state) and the local emergency response commission. We also responded to multiple toxic tort class action suits filed after the incident.
  • Oil Spill – Baker Hostetler represented the time charterer of a tanker that was involved in an oil spill of 400,000 gallons of crude oil off Huntington Beach, California. For several weeks, the firm helped staff the client's emergency response office and represented the client in all aspects of the spill litigation, including a natural resources damage claim under state law and the Clean Water Act, and the resultant class action litigation.
  • Phosphogypsum Tailings Release – Our attorneys represented one of the major oil companies in managing the immediate environmental crisis and in resolving property damage claims and personal injury claims after a 40 million gallon acidic spill in the Houston Ship Channel.
  • Structural Failure – Emergency site management, reporting and coordination of OSHA investigation after the collapse of steel framing for a major hotel under construction, as well as coordination of indemnities and subrogation interests. Involved property damage and personal injuries.

About Baker Hostetler's Litigation Team

When the stakes are bet-the-company monetary damages, potential criminal sentences and intense scrutiny in the court of public opinion, the 200-plus litigators of Baker Hostetler are a team to depend on. We have the kind of credentials you expect from a leading national litigation firm and a client base we have protected in and out of court for decades.

What really sets us apart is our practical experience as trial lawyers. The Baker Hostetler team includes former top prosecutors of the U.S. Justice Department (four of whom received the Attorney General's Distinguished Services Award), former prosecutors for major municipalities, veteran civil trial attorneys and enforcement officials from various federal agencies, from the Department of Energy to the SEC and NASD (now FINRA).

Leadership in Action
Product Liability: Establishing an effective strategy for pesticide litigation defense
Client: Pesticide Manufacturers
Type of Matter: Product liability defense
Our Client's Challenge: Numerous lawsuits have been brought against our clients for alleged injuries and damages involving use of pesticide products.
The Goal: Demonstrate that federal law shields our client from product liability allegations.
Our Strategy: Baker Hostetler was a leader in developing the argument that the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) preempts the claims based directly or indirectly on products warnings.
Results: We have won numerous cases with this defense and written amicus briefs in the Texas Supreme Court and the United States Supreme Court on this issue.


Litigation—Product Liability and Toxic Tort Lawyers
Mary Price Birk Partner
Denver 303.764.4041
Mary M. Bittence Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7361
Seanna R. Brown Associate
New York 212.589.4230
Kelly S. Burgan Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7395
John H. Burtch Partner
Columbus 614.462.2644
Matthew W. Caligur Partner
Houston 713.646.1355
Joseph L. Chairez Partner
Costa Mesa 714.966.8822
Diane P. Chapman Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7343
S. Jeanine Conley Associate
New York 212.589.4635
Cory M. Curtis Associate
Denver 303.764.4024
Douglas D. D'Arche Partner
Houston 713.646.1379
Rebecca Jackson Doty Associate
Houston 713.646.1370
Denis L. Durkin Partner
Orlando 407.649.4053
Paul S. Enockson Partner
Denver 303.764.4017
James V. Etscorn Partner
Orlando 407.649.4067
Diane L. Feigi Staff Attorney
Cleveland 216.861.6509
Ryan Fischbach Partner
Los Angeles 310.442.8898
Eric R. Fish Associate
New York 212.589.4647
Paul S. Francis Partner
Houston 713.646.1334
Peder A. Garske Partner
Washington, DC 202.861.1763
Robin E. Harvey Partner
Cincinnati 513.929.3409
William H. Hawkins II Counsel
Cincinnati 513.929.3481
Angela M. Hayden Associate
Cincinnati 513.929.3410
Ronald L. Hellbusch Staff Attorney
Denver 303.764.4032
Dean D. Hunt Partner
Houston 713.646.1346
Michael N. Hutter Staff Attorney
Orlando 407.649.4034
Eric W. Kristiansen Partner
Houston 713.646.1331
Albert P. Mayer Associate
Denver 303.764.4047
Michael W. Mengis Partner
Houston 713.646.1330
Wade A. Mitchell Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7971
James L. Moore Partner
Houston 713.646.1374
Edward D. Papp Associate
Cleveland 216.861.7830
Michelle D. Pector Partner
Houston 713.646.1326
John W. Petrelli III Associate
Houston 713.646.1340
Ben L. Pfefferle III Partner
Columbus 614.462.2601
Patricia A. Poole Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7661
Robert T. Razzano Associate
Cincinnati 513.929.3494
Lora M. Reece Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7146
David J. Sheehan Partner
New York 212.589.4616
Randall L. Solomon Partner
Cleveland 216.861.7327
Hugh C. Thatcher Associate
Denver 303.764.4098
Gregory C. Ulmer Partner
Houston 713.646.1363
James C. Winton Partner
Houston 713.646.1304
Cole A. Wist Partner
Denver 303.764.4020

For more information about our Product Liability & Toxic Tort:
National Contact
James V. Etscorn 407.649.4067

Chicago
Ronald S. Okada 312.416.6210

Cincinnati

Robin E. Harvey 513.929.3409

Cleveland

Wade A. Mitchell 216.861.7971
Patricia A. Poole 216.861.7661
Randall L. Solomon 216.861.7327

Columbus

Mark A. Johnson 614.462.2698

Costa Mesa

George Mooradian 714.966.8800

Denver

Mary Price Birk 303.764.4041

Houston

James L. Moore 713.646.1374

Gregory C. Ulmer 713.646.1363

Los Angeles

Lisa I. Carteen 310.979.8450

New York

Gerald J. Ferguson 212.589.4238

Orlando

James V. Etscorn 407.649.4067

Scott E. Damon 407.649.4071

Washington, DC

Lee T. Ellis 202.861.1521

Contact

National Contact
James V. Etscorn
407.649.4067


Contacts by Office »

Representative Clients

Bayer Corporation

Beverly Enterprises

Euclid Chemical

Ford Motor Company

Hughes Supply, Inc.

Northrop Grumman Corporation

Pentair Water

Sta-Rite Industries, Inc.

Practice Highlights

Class action experience involving millions of class members and billions of dollars in claims.

National and regional counsel for numerous product manufacturers and distributors.

Premier asbestos and silica defense practice.

Experienced in hundreds of breast implant, DES and tobacco cases.

Vast experience in refinery disasters.

Emergency response team available 24/7 for environmental disasters, including chemical spills.

One of the nation's leading toxic tort litigation practices with attorneys in all ten of our offices.

Significant experience in OSHA investigations involving clients'products and chemical spills.