On Nov. 10, U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) Director John A. Squires announced that merits-based institution decisions in inter partes reviews (IPRs) and post-grant reviews (PGRs) will be delegated once more to Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) panels. In doing so, the Director renewed emphasis on the statutory thresholds that govern IPR and PGR institutions and identified scenarios where petitions fall short of these thresholds. For America Invents Act (AIA) petitioners, the Director’s guidance signals strict application of statutory thresholds to their petitions; for patent owners, it creates additional pre-institution opportunities to defeat review. The stakes have been raised once more.
What Is Changing?
Since October 2025, the USPTO Director has exercised centralized authority over institution decisions in IPR and PGR proceedings. According to the memorandum, that process was intended to increase accountability, promote transparency, eliminate perceived bias and separate institution decisions from later trial proceedings.
Under the new framework, institution decisions will once again be divided into two stages:
Director Review of Non-Merits Issues
- The Director will continue to review discretionary denial considerations and other issues unrelated to the substantive validity challenges raised in a petition.
- The Director may deny institution based on those considerations.
PTAB Review of Merits Issues
- Petitions that survive Director review will be referred to a three-member PTAB panel.
- The panel will determine whether the petition satisfies the statutory institution requirements under 35 U.S.C. §§ 314(a) and 324(a).
The existing briefing process for discretionary-denial issues and merits issues remains unchanged.
Why the USPTO Made the Change
Squires explained that the last year of centralized review demonstrated that PTAB judges are well-positioned to evaluate the merits of patentability challenges.
The memorandum reports that the Director’s office evaluated more than 325 institution decisions involving merits issues and developed a body of precedent addressing common institution questions. It also points to operational initiatives such as the USPTO’s LOOP (Learning from Outcomes to Optimize Patents) and PTAB STRONG programs, which were designed to improve consistency between examination and post-grant practice.
According to the Director, these efforts have increased confidence that PTAB judges can apply institution standards consistently while allowing the Director to focus on policy-related discretionary issues.
New Merits Review Guidance for PTAB Panels
The memorandum reminds PTAB judges that the AIA bars institution of IPR and PGR when statutory thresholds are not met. Discretion has no role in an institution decision when a petition fails to demonstrate that “there is a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail with respect to at least 1” challenged claim (35 U.S.C. § 314(a)) or that “it is more likely than not that at least 1 of the challenged claims” is unpatentable (35 U.S.C. § 324(a)). Petitions must be denied in these circumstances.
The memorandum provides substantive guidance to PTAB panels when evaluating institution.
1. Petitioners Must Present Detailed Prior-Art Mappings.
For prior-art-based grounds, PTAB panels are instructed to require petitioners to explain specifically how each claim limitation is taught or rendered obvious by the cited references. Generalized assertions, conclusory expert testimony or mere reliance on examiner findings will not suffice. The petition must provide a clear, element-by-element explanation identifying the particular portions of the prior art relied upon.
2. Institution Will Be Denied When a Petition Fails To Make a Requisite Showing for a Substantial Majority of Challenged Claims.
The memorandum states that PTAB panels should deny institution where a petitioner fails to establish the required statutory showing for a substantial majority of the challenged claims. Earlier PTAB decisions declined institution where only a small subset of challenges appeared persuasive. The memorandum directs PTAB panels to deny institution in such circumstances going forward.
3. Strong, Well-Supported Patent Owner Preliminary Responses Can Defeat Institution.
The memorandum directs panels to deny institution if a patent owner’s preliminary response presents a reasonable argument, supported by reliable and credible evidence, showing that the petitioner fails to satisfy the institution standard for a substantial majority of challenged claims.
This instruction reinforces the strategic importance of preliminary responses and may encourage patent owners to invest additional resources at the pre-institution stage.
4. PTAB Panels May Raise Merits Deficiencies Independently.
Even if the patent owner does not identify a weakness, PTAB panels are directed to deny institution when they independently conclude that the petitioner has not made the required showing for most challenged claims.
The guidance therefore suggests a more active gatekeeping role for institution panels.
5. A Tie Goes to the Patent Owner.
The memorandum directs the PTAB to deny institution when the arguments both for and against unpatentability of a particular challenged claim are reasonably supported when considering all the evidence. When evidence is in equipoise, a petitioner would have failed to show that “there is a reasonable likelihood that the petitioner would prevail” with respect to a challenged claim (35 U.S.C. § 314(a)) or that “it is more likely than not that at least 1 of the claims challenged in the petition is unpatentable” (35 U.S.C. § 324(a)). Here, the memorandum invokes the reasonable likelihood standard that applies for preliminary injunctions, where a movant must show that it “will likely prove” its case “in light of the presumptions and burdens that will inhere at trial on the merits.” Uncertainty weighs against institution because the burden rests on the petitioner.
6. These Merits-Based Factors Are Not Exhaustive.
The memorandum identifies the foregoing factors as providing examples where a petitioner failed to meet its institution burden, but they are not exhaustive. The Director notes that other scenarios may arise that “indicate that a petitioner fails to meet its institution burden, such as a prior adjudication that claims of the challenged patent or a related patent are not invalid or not unpatentable.” Thus, patent owners have other analytical paths available to them to argue that a petition failed to meet its burden to institute review.
Separation Between Institution and Trial Panels
To preserve the separation between institution and final adjudication, the USPTO will maintain a two-panel approach. If a PTAB panel institutes review, a new panel composed of different PTAB judges will conduct the trial. Judges participating in the institution decision will not participate in the final merits proceeding.
This aspect of the memorandum is designed to address concerns regarding potential confirmation bias and maintain confidence in the fairness of PTAB proceedings.
What Is NOT Changing?
Importantly, the memorandum does not restore the pre-2025 institution framework. The Director retains authority to deny institution of AIA reviews based on discretionary factors and, of course, to set broader institution policy. The Director will send a petition that passes his review to a PTAB panel to complete a merits-based institution determination.
Looking Ahead
The USPTO’s latest change reflects an effort to balance centralized policy control with PTAB adjudicatory expertise. The Director states that the past year’s centralized-review process brought USPTO practice “more in-line with the AIA. … For example, in June 2025, about 60% of petitions were discretionarily denied and about 40% of petitions were referred for a review of the merits. In contrast, in September 2026, [the Director] discretionarily denied 15% of petitions and referred 85% of petitions for a review of the merits.” The memorandum expresses full confidence that PTAB judges will be “strong and judicious stewards for merits-based considerations” in future institution decisions.
For practitioners, the memorandum heralds important developments for AIA reviews:
- Petition quality at filing remains important.
- Broad petitions challenging many claims without particularized support for each claim may face heightened institution risk.
- Patent owners will be motivated to develop well-reasoned preliminary responses that are grounded in reliable evidence.
- Institution decisions will briefly address the merits considerations the panel found important and explain whether the petitioner satisfied the applicable standard for at least one claim and one asserted ground. They need not address every ground or argument.
- Parties should expect PTAB institution decisions to focus on whether pre-institution briefing demonstrates a persuasive case of invalidity across a majority of challenged claims. Presentation of an invalidity argument that merely “checks the boxes” may not suffice.




