Skip to Main Content
11/19/2026|3 minute read

On Nov. 12, the NYC Council overwhelmingly approved legislation that would prohibit entities domiciled or transacting with consumers in New York City from using consumers’ personal data to set individualized prices for the same goods and services. With the passage of this measure, New York City joins the growing list of state and municipal jurisdictions that are moving to ban the practice known as “surveillance” or “personalized” pricing.

From Personalization to Prohibition

The bill would prohibit entities and third parties acting on their behalf from using algorithms and customers’ personal data to offer different prices to different customers for the same goods or services. It also reaches upstream conduct by (a) restricting the collection, sale, or sharing of personal information for the purpose of facilitating surveillance pricing and (b) prohibiting the advertisement or offer to a customer using surveillance pricing.

Not every personalized deal or dynamic price is banned. Businesses may continue to offer certain “bona fide discounts,” including through conventional promotions, sales, or coupons. Businesses may also offer “bona fide custom discounts,” such as through a loyalty, membership, or rewards program, provided that (a) the customer affirmatively and knowingly enrolled in the program, (b) the discount is clearly and conspicuously disclosed to all program members in a given local geographic market, or commonly used distribution channel, and (c) the program has publicly disclosed terms and conditions. Loyalty, membership, and rewards programs may also offer tiers of bona fide discounts to customers based on prior purchase history data, provided that (1) the tiers are clearly and conspicuously disclosed and (2) such prior purchase history data is not paired, combined, or cross-referenced with any other personal data except enrollment in the loyalty, membership, or rewards program. The legislation contains additional exceptions for certain regulated activities, including insurance and credit-related pricing.

Entities that use surveillance pricing in connection with the offering of a bona fide custom discount must develop and maintain reasonable procedures for consumers to request and receive information regarding what personal data is considered and how such personal data is considered when setting particular prices.

Violations may be subject to civil penalties of up to $1,000 per violation plus actual damages sustained by consumers. Each affected consumer or transaction can constitute a separate violation, which means exposure could add up quickly for businesses operating pricing systems at scale. Importantly, there is no private right of action.

Notably, the city’s bill creates a separate enforcement mechanism against qualifying NYC-domiciled small businesses whose first offense will trigger a mandatory notice with up to 30 days to cure or demonstrate corrective action, including providing restitution to affected consumers. And all businesses will have some runway, as the measure is set to take effect one year after it is signed into law.

Another Piece of the Pricing Puzzle

With the passage of this bill, New York City becomes the second municipality to address surveillance pricing. Earlier in September, Seattle became the first to enact a city-level surveillance-pricing restriction. And as we previously wrote about, Connecticut, Maryland, and New Jersey adopted state laws restricting certain uses of consumer information in pricing, and the Federal Trade Commission has issued a policy statement putting businesses on notice that the use of “personalized” pricing without clear disclosure could violate Section 5 of the FTC Act.

Interestingly, New York state was the first to pass a law regarding algorithmic pricing. However, this law did not ban the practice; it merely required businesses to disclose when such a practice was used. Earlier this year, New York state lawmakers passed the One Fair Price Act, which, as we discussed here, would create a prohibition on surveillance pricing; however, as of the date of publication, it was still awaiting action by Gov. Kathy Hochul.

Unfortunately, this patchwork of state – and now city – laws can create some confusion, as the laws are anything but copy/paste. For example, New Jersey’s Fair Price Protection Act focuses on “groceries and foodstuffs,” whereas New York City’s measure extends to the pricing of goods and services, making its potential application considerably broader.

For companies operating across multiple jurisdictions, this patchwork may create compliance challenges, requiring a businesses to take stock of the specific data, pricing practices, products, services, and exceptions in each applicable market.


Featured Insights